Zinc and Zotero 10, side by side

Start-up, memory and search speed, measured on one Windows 11 x64 machine. Numbers move from run to run on a busy machine (the ranges below show by how much), so read them as a guide, not a promise.

The speed register

The same library in both programs: a copy of a real library with about 12.4k top-level items (28.5k counting attachments and notes). Zotero is the installed Zotero 10.0.7 (Windows x64) on a copy of its own data folder; Zinc is the installed AOT build on a copy of the same library. Three runs of each, the app closed between runs, results shown as median (range).

MeasureZotero 10.0.7Zinc
Window on screen1.83 srange 1.81–1.89 s0.49 s3.7× fasterrange 0.49–3.30 s
Library ready (local data API answers)16.3 srange 16.2–16.4 s0.70 s23× fasterrange 0.64–3.5 s
Memory, working set, whole process tree783 MBrange 757–887 MB358 MB54% lessrange 358–364 MB
Processes31
Search through the local API, common word (3.4k to 4.5k hits)1872 msrange 1823–1890 ms50 ms37× fasterrange 49–53 ms
Search through the local API, author (107 to 550 hits)1957 msrange 1940–1967 ms35 ms56× fasterrange 35–35 ms
Search through the local API, rare word (1 hit)2036 msrange 1926–2043 ms39 ms52× fasterrange 38–39 ms
Search through the local API, year (821 hits)1957 msrange 1759–1998 ms39 ms50× fasterrange 39–40 ms
Program folder241 MB330 MB
Library database175 MB368 MB

Lower is better in every row. Each figure is the median of three runs, with their range underneath; the green note shows how far ahead Zinc is where it leads.

How this was measured
  • Window on screen: time from starting the process until the first visible top-level window owned by it or its children appears (the script polls EnumWindows every 5 ms). For Zotero that first window is its main window before the library is shown; the window titled with the library appeared at 4.6 s (4.5 to 4.7). Both apps were started minimised, without taking focus.
  • Library ready: time until the program's local data API answers a request for one top-level item (Zotero: /api/users/0/items/top?limit=1, which waits for the library's items to load; Zinc: /api/items?limit=1). This is a stand-in for "the items are loaded", not for "the first row is painted". Zotero 10's API gave an error and then stopped answering when it was called before its start-up had finished, so the first request is sent only after its main window shows the library; its figure is therefore the later of the two. The slowest Zinc runs are the first launch from a fresh settings folder (3.3 s window, 3.5 s ready); the other two were 0.49 s and 0.64 to 0.70 s.
  • Memory: working set (the memory the app holds in RAM) summed over the whole process tree, sampled 12 s after "ready". Zinc runs its core in the same process, so one process holds the library.
  • Search: ten timed calls after one untimed call, per query, per run, with the whole JSON response read. Zotero: /api/users/0/items/top?q=...&qmode=titleCreatorYear&limit=25; Zinc: /api/items?q=...&limit=25. The queries were picked from the library: a common title word, the commonest author surname, a rare title word and the commonest year. These are HTTP API times, not typing-in-the-search-box times: Zotero's own search box does not go through this API, and the API adds the cost of building full JSON for each item. The two programs also do not match the same set of items (for the common word 4514 and 3441 hits), so compare them as "one search request", not as identical work.
  • Sizes: the program folder (C:\Program Files\Zotero; %LOCALAPPDATA%\Programs\Zinc) and the library database file (zotero.sqlite; Zinc's library). They hold different things, so this is not a like-for-like data size.
  • Isolation: Zotero ran from a new profile (-profile, -no-remote) with its data folder set to a copy, sync, updates and background renaming off, and its local API on port 23131. Zinc ran on a copy with sync off, its own ports and scratch settings folders. Neither the real Zotero nor the real Zinc library was written to. Copies were deleted afterwards.
  • Not measured: opening a PDF (it cannot be timed fairly without driving the mouse or keyboard); typing speed and scrolling in Zotero (the scroll figures below are Zinc only). A first launch of a new Zotero profile (not counted) took 1.25 s to a window, 5.5 s to the library title and 17.0 s to ready.

Zinc on its own

The AOT build, the one the installer ships:

MeasureResult
First items on screen399 ms
Memory in use (working set)334 MB
Scroll, cards view126 to 129 fps
Scroll, Classic table68 to 103 fps

Two more figures: the first reading-view layout of a 10-page PDF takes about 5 to 6 s, and inspecting a Find Full Text result takes 45 ms.

How measured: start-up and memory with gpui-ui/scripts/aot-bench.ts (it launches the build, waits for the window and the app's own "first items" mark, then samples the working set). Scrolling with gpui-ui/scripts/scroll-bench.ts (wheel-scrolls the list in a real window at a fixed speed and counts frames GPUI draws per second, cards and table). Both read a copy of a library, never the original. These come from different scripts and set-ups from the table above, so do not read them across. gpui-ui/scripts/README.md describes both scripts and the other measurements.

The feature register

"Zotero 10" means the desktop app (checked against version 10.0.7) with no extra plugins unless noted. The Zotero column was checked against the files of an installed Zotero 10.0.7 (its interface strings, preferences and code). "Unverified" means the install could not confirm the point.

AreaZotero 10ZincNotes
Library, collections and sub-collectionsYesYesCollection colours, icons, pins and sections are extras, kept locally and not synced.
Saved searchesYesPartlyWork locally and import from Zotero. They do not sync to zotero.org.
Tags, tag colours, automatic tagsYesYes
PDF reader and annotationsYesPartlyNext: highlight, underline, note, ink, image, eraser. Zotero 10 also has a Text annotation tool, which Next does not. Printing a PDF from Next does not include reader annotations.
Reading view (reflowed article)YesYesZotero 10 has a Reading Mode button for PDFs and web snapshots. Next adds figures and tables as cards, and reference and citation cards. Zotero 10's reader code also has reference and citation popups, so how far the two differ is unverified.
Read AloudYesNoZotero 10: text-to-speech with local voices; its online voices need a Zotero login.
NotesYesYesRich editor, child and standalone notes.
Attachments and notes under items in the listYesYesA twisty opens child rows, in Cards and in the Classic table.
Snapshots and EPUBYesYesOpened in web tabs.
Sync with zotero.orgYesPartlyItems, collections, tags, notes, annotations and files. Your own library and your group libraries (read-only groups never upload).
Sync through a local Zoteron/aYesReads and writes the Zotero data folder.
Word pluginYesYesWord only, with a sidebar.
LibreOffice pluginYesNoZotero 10 ships the LibreOffice extension. Not planned for Next.
Google DocsYesNoZotero 10 handles Google Docs through the browser connector (the install has the integration code); not tested end to end, so unverified. Not planned for Next.
Browser connectorYesYesWorks with the official connector on port 23119, or with the native-messaging fork, which also opens your library in a browser tab where you can edit it.
Translators, import and exportYesYesZotero's own translators, plus native importers for common formats.
Citation stylesYesYesciteproc-js and CSL styles.
Drag citations into other appsYesYesDrop items on Word, a browser or an email to insert the Quick Copy text; Shift gives a citation instead of a bibliography entry. Windows only in Next.
Institutional access for PDFsYesYesZotero 10 uses library proxy settings. Next adds a sign-in window for OpenAthens, Shibboleth and library proxies, and keeps the session between runs.
Better BibTeXPartlyYesIn Zotero it is a third-party plugin. Zotero 10 has a Citation Key field, but no key formulas, pinned keys or auto-export were found in its own files. Built in here: keys, exports, auto-export, endpoints.
ZotMoovPartlyYesA third-party plugin in Zotero. Zotero 10 has built-in file renaming, but no move-to-folder feature was found. The ideas are built in here.
Find Full TextYesYesZotero calls it Find Available PDF.
Locate enginesYesYesZotero calls them Lookup Engines.
Duplicate detection and mergeYesYes
My PublicationsYesYes
Group librariesYesPartlySynced through zotero.org: sidebar section, collections, items, tags and adding items. Not yet for group Trash, saved searches or a local-Zotero route.
Plugins and extensionsYesNoExisting Zotero plugins cannot run. Features register through an internal registry instead.
macOS and LinuxYesPartlyLinux x86-64 (AppImage) and Apple Silicon Macs (disk image). The Word add-in, the closed-app connector, auto-update and the Find Full Text sign-in window are Windows only. For Zotero 10 this is unverified: the install checked here is the Windows build.
Mobile appsYesNoUnverified for Zotero 10 (a desktop install cannot show it). Sync through zotero.org and use Zotero's own mobile apps.
Local API for other programsYesYesZotero 10: an HTTP API on the Zotero Connector port, off by default (a preference turns it on). Next: the core's HTTP API.
MCP server for AI agentsNoYesIn the core, and in the Word add-in. No MCP server was found in the Zotero 10 install.